Thursday, June 6, 2013



In the colony where I live in Pune almost all children have migrated to the USA to realize the American Dream. 

This includes the girls too.  

That is the reason why Computer Science, Software Engineering and IT is so popular.

It is the easiest way to go abroad. 

But one thing is very funny about this Indian (Puneri) diaspora. 

In their professional lives and careers they quickly adopt modern western American values but in their personal lives they still cling on to traditional Indian values. 

They are not confused desis. 

Far from it. 

They want the best of both worlds. 

So most of the time they keep summoning their parents (especially the mothers and mothers-in-law) to America to look after them and their households.

On the other hand, they in turn care two hoots for their old parents left back in India to fend for themselves. 

It is high time they followed the proverb:


The fiction short story below BEST OF BOTH WORLDS explores this dichotomy. 

I had written this story a few years ago. 

This is fiction, but let me tell you that I have seen many instances of this happening in real life.

In fact, it is happening right now to my neighbour whose wife has abandoned him and gone to America for more than six months to look after her daughter's one year old son. 

She had gone last year too for about six months for her delivery too and the mother and mother-in-law take turns going abroad to do their “duty” running their children's families leaving their hapless husbands back home to fend for themselves. 

Do American parents do the same? 

Do American children exploit their parents in the same way and make them do surrogate parenting

I don't know. 

Please read the story and tell me what you think.


A Short Story

This story is a work of fiction. The characters do not exist and are purely imaginary. Any resemblance to persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental.

A middle aged woman watches the sun set from the balcony of her tenth floor flat of one of those ubiquitous residential “townships” rapidly sprawling and proliferating around the once remote suburb of Aundh on the outskirts of the once beautiful and picturesque city of Pune in western India.

The doorbell rings. It’s her husband back home from work.

He’s tired and aching all over after the long bone-rattling, back-breaking and lung-choking commute on the terrible roads and in the polluted atmosphere.

“Good news,” his wife says exuberantly, giving him his customary cup of tea.

“What?” the husband asks nonchalantly, carefully pouring the precise amount of tea from the cup into the saucer and lifting the saucer to his lips to enjoy his tea in his usual habitual manner.

“Our daughter Nalini is pregnant,” the wife exults.

“At long last – I thought she didn’t have time for mundane things like procreation –  I am so glad she found time from her busy schedule,” the husband comments acerbically and noisily sips his tea in his customary acerbic style.

“Don’t be sarcastic. She’s a career woman. Aren’t you happy...?”

“Of course I’m happy. I’m 56 now – it’s high time I became a grandfather.”

“I’ll have to go...”


“For her delivery.”

“To Seattle...?”

“Yes. Her due date is sometime in December. I better go as early as possible, maybe in October. Poor thing, it’s her first child. You better get the visas and all ready well in time. Nalini wants me to stay for at least three-four months after her delivery.”

“Three-four months after her delivery...? So you’ll be away for more than six months...?”

“Yes. I’m her mother and I have to be there to help her. Poor thing. It’s her first delivery. And that too in America... poor thing...”

“Poor thing...? Who asked her to go there...? And what about me...?”

“You also come and help out.”

“I won’t get six months’ leave.”

“Come for a month. To see the baby. In December or January...”

“I’ll see. But I don’t like it there. It’s too boring. And in December it will be freezing cold.”

“Then stay here.”

“I wish we hadn’t shifted from Sadashiv Peth.”

“Why...? Isn’t this lovely apartment better than those two horrible rented rooms we had...? And it’s all thanks to Nalini.”

“I know... I know... Don’t rub it in. But sometimes I wish we hadn’t pushed her into Computers and IT. We should have let her study arts, history, literature – whatever she wanted to.”

“And it would have been difficult to find a decent boy for her and she would be languishing like an ordinary housewife with no future... slogging away throughout her life like me.”

“And we would be still staying in the heart of the city and not in the wilderness out here... and you wouldn’t have to go all the way to America for her delivery...!”

“Don’t change the topic....” the wife says.

“I am not changing the topic,” says the husband firmly. “You are not going for Nalini’s delivery to America. Let them, she and her husband, manage on her own.”

“But why shouldn’t I go...? She is sending the ticket.”

“It’s not a question of money. The fact is I don’t want to stay all alone at this age. It is difficult. And here, in this godforsaken township full of snobs, I don’t even have any friends.”

“Try to understand. I have to be there. It’s her first delivery.”

“Tell me one thing.”


“Don’t the women out there have babies...?”

“Yes. So...?”

“And do they always have their mothers around pampering them during their pregnancies and deliveries...? And then mollycoddling their babies for the next few months, maybe even a year...?”

“I don’t know,” she said evading an answer, “for them it’s different.”


“Our girls are najuk.”


“Delicate.... fragile.”

“Nonsense. They are as tough as any one else. It’s all in the mind. It’s only our mindset that’s different.”

“What do you mean...?”

“Thousands of women who have migrated from all over the world are delivering babies out there every day, but it’s only our girls who can’t do without their mothers around, is it...?”

“Don’t argue with me. It’s our culture... our tradition. A daughter’s first delivery is her mother’s responsibility.”

“Culture...? Tradition...? What nonsense...? It’s not culture... it’s attitude...! Our people may have physically migrated to the modern world, but their mental make-up hasn’t changed, isn’t it...?”

“Please stop your lecturing. I’m fed up of hearing…” the wife pleads.

The husband continues as if he hasn’t heard her: “What they require is attitudinal change and to stop their double standards. Nonsense... Nobody forced them to go to America... They went there on their own and it’s high time they adopt the American way of life instead of clinging on to roots and values they themselves have cast off…”

“Please. Please. Please. Enough... I beg of you. Don’t argue. Just let me go.”

“No. You can't go. I can’t stay alone for six months. Why should I...?”

“Try to understand. I’ve told you a hundred times. It’s our only daughter’s first delivery. I have to be there.”

“Okay. Tell her to come here.”


“Yes. Here. To Pune. We’ll do her delivery right here in Pune. We’ll go to the best maternity hospital and then you can keep her here as long as you want. She’ll be comfortable, the weather will be good and you can pamper your darling daughter and her baby to your heart’s content.”


“What do you mean ‘No’...? You went to your mother’s place for your deliveries isn’t it...? And you came back after the babies were more than three months old.”

“That was different. I wasn’t working.”

“Oh. It’s about her job is it...? I’m sure they have maternity leave out there. She can take a break. Come here to India. Have her baby. And if she wants to go back early we’ll look after the kid for a couple of months and then I’ll take leave and we’ll both go and drop the baby there.”

The wife says nothing.

“Give me the phone. I’ll ring her up and tell her to come here as early as possible. I’ll convince her she will be more comfortable here,” the husband says.

“I’ve already spoken to her and tried to convince her exactly what you suggested,” the wife says.


“She wants the baby to be born there. It’s something about citizenship.”

“So that’s the point...” the husband says, “She wants the best of both worlds, isn’t it...?”

Copyright © Vikram Karve 2013
Vikram Karve has asserted his right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 to be identified as the author of this book review. 
© vikram karve., all rights reserved.

1. All stories in this blog are a work of fiction. The characters do not exist and are purely imaginary. Any resemblance to persons, living or dead, is purely coincidental. 
2. No part of this Blog may be reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical including photocopying or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the Blog Author Vikram Karve who holds the copyright. 
Copyright © Vikram Karve 2013 all rights reserved

Did you like this story?
I am sure you will like the 27 short stories from my recently published anthology of Short Fiction COCKTAIL
To order your COCKTAIL please click any of the links below:
If you prefer reading ebooks on Kindle or your ebook reader, please order Cocktail E-book by clicking the links below:

Foodie Book:  Appetite for a Stroll
If your are a Foodie you will like my book of Food Adventures APPETITE FOR A STROLL. Do order a copy from FLIPKART:

About Vikram Karve

A creative person with a zest for life, Vikram Karve is a retired Naval Officer turned full time writer and blogger. Educated at IIT Delhi, IIT (BHU) Varanasi, The Lawrence School Lovedale and Bishops School Pune, Vikram has published two books: COCKTAIL a collection of fiction short stories about relationships (2011) and APPETITE FOR A STROLL a book of Foodie Adventures (2008) and is currently working on his novel and a book of vignettes and an anthology of short fiction. An avid blogger, he has written a number of fiction short stories and creative non-fiction articles on a variety of topics including food, travel, philosophy, academics, technology, management, health, pet parenting, teaching stories and self help in magazines and published a large number of professional  and academic research papers in journals and edited in-house journals and magazines for many years, before the advent of blogging. Vikram has taught at a University as a Professor for 15 years and now teaches as a visiting faculty and devotes most of his time to creative writing and blogging. Vikram Karve lives in Pune India with his family and muse - his pet dog Sherry with whom he takes long walks thinking creative thoughts.

Vikram Karve Academic and Creative Writing Journal:
Professional Profile Vikram Karve:
Vikram Karve Facebook Page:
Vikram Karve Creative Writing Blog:
Twitter: @vikramkarve
© vikram karve., all rights reserved.


Mahesh said...

Well written. Note I am not saying "well written story" :) We see so many examples of these. In fact, after some years, some of these families actually come back to India feeling safe that their child is a US citizen. So even if something bad happens here, he can go back to US and be safe and sound. Another twist of the story is in most cases grand parents are very supportive of the "best of both worlds" theory. However, only after few years they realize that their grandchildren talk to them in a accent which they don't understand and neither they are on the same plane where talking to them makes any sense. After all, grand parents still are in the third world. I am not saying this is all wrong, in fact, this is all logical to a great extent. Just that this is not organic growth.

Sonia Arora said...

I'm one such person too, been brought up the western way but eventually after reading ur posts, I never asked my parents to part for the sake of their children and in one such instance when I had fallen really ill and my mother suggested she stay with me until i was better, i was cross and said " u are not coming here in UK mum, dad needs u to be around and I will not do this to u anyway. topic closed, ur not coming "
Dad came to see me anyway out of worry and I sent him back in 3 days. I suppose I will always follow this, I wont separate my parents because I need them. yes, I'm really western in that matter because I've been loved unconditionally by my parents as one unit and I'll always appreciate it that way from them. Time we grow up our own babies on our own.

Unknown said... are right....people always want the best of everything. And we, at micro level, should start changing it. For example, take the custom of marriage. Traditionally parents are supposed to take care of children's wedding expenses and then children are supposed to take care of aging parents. If aren't taking care of the latter, then why demand former?

Swatee said...

I am one such daughter who is also in the USA. Time and again i see people and including you Mr Karve demand an answer from both parties. With no offense to you or anyone, its a matter of choice. My parents made a choice for me, more so than i made for myself. They encouraged all three kids of theirs to learn and grow. The intention was for our future with no expectations in return. I learnt exactly the same thing and i will make sure my kids get the same freedom to do what they wish to or is good for them in their future.

I had a baby 18 months ago and my mom was here to help me then my in laws came right after. To the extent that they had a knowledge transfer week between themselves.Now i am expecting the next one and my parents are coming again. But the whole notion they are coming to take care of their daughter is not the only advantage here. Grandparents also get to travel, have fun with the kids and get loads of love from the reunion. My parents are travelers, if they don't come to the US or Australia they are travelling local within the country. I don't see why coming to spend quality time with their own kids is anything different, than us going there.

I grew up with my grandparents around and i want the same for my kids. Without being selfish i am moving back to India so they get to spend a whole lot more time with the grand kids. I wanted citizenship for my kids because i prefer for them to chose in the future to be where they want to be. I personally went through hell with the whole immigration process, i rather have them as many options open.

I might sound emotional but i am tried of people judging without being in the "DAUGHTERS/SON" shoes and just commenting . I love my parents to death, and i am what i am because my parents.