Happiness & Pleasure
Are Happiness and Pleasure correlated...? Or are they mutually exclusive...?
1. Pleasure is Quantitative; Happiness is Qualitative
2. Happiness is a lifelong goal
3. Happiness requires cognitive judgment
4. Pleasure is not essential to achieving happiness – here I do not agree. I feel happiness and pleasure are not mutually exclusive - in fact genuine pleasure can be the source of much happiness.
No philosopher has better explored the distinction between happiness and pleasure than Epicurus, a Greek Philosopher of the Third Century BC.
Epicurus (341-270 BC) espoused a strategy for achieving genuine human happiness by emphasizing the delights of the mind (over which a person has control) rather than the delights derived from material things (which are so often beyond one's personal control).
Epicurus' name survives in the team "epicurean" which is used to refer to someone with elevated tastes and a lifestyle centred on pleasure. However, if you peruse his philosophy thoroughly, you will realize that Epicurus counsels a way of life very different from what the popular use of the term "pleasure" implies.
You may feel that Epicurean philosophy champions the pursuit of pleasure as the supreme goal of life, but this does not mean the unrestrained pursuit of excesses of any kind. Instead, Epicurus argues for a life of sober restrain and moderation in all things. The pleasures Epicurus recommends are those that are easy to achieve and simple in nature. The prolonged pursuit of pleasure is best achieved by restraint and enlightened choice.
It may be the prudent to moderate our single minded pursuit of "outward" success and achievement, the mindless acquisition of material possessions and accumulation of wealth, tendencies to showing off and ostentation, conspicuous consumption and lavish unrestrained pleasures; and focus more on the more authentic "inner" pleasures of life such as happy family life, enriching relationships, cultivating the mind and intellect, enjoying the pleasures of friends and companions, and living on the higher plane.
Epicureanism does not advocate the wanton pursuit of pleasure. Also, you must remember that pleasures and pains of the mind are of greater importance than those of the body. Epicurus set forth a strategy for achieving authentic human happiness by emphasizing the delights of the mind (over which a person has control) rather than the delights derived from material things (which are so often beyond one's personal control). The fundamental premise is that presence of pleasure is synonymous with the absence of pain.
Genuine happiness emanates from pleasures that are easy to achieve and simple in nature.
If you have only a few things, we will enjoy them more than if you had many things, and if you do not become used to rich and expensive foods, then simple fare, which is easier to obtain will satisfy you more.
In a nutshell: "The Art of Happiness is in keeping your Pleasures Mild".
And how do you keep your pleasures mild...?
Desire & Pleasure
Are pleasures in any way linked to satisfying your desires?
There are two different types of pleasures:
'Moving' Pleasures occur when one is in the process of satisfying a desire – like eating delicious food when one is hungry. These moving pleasures involve an active enjoyable titillation of the senses which most people commonly understand as "pleasure" since this feeling can be easily experienced.
However, Epicurus says that after one's desires have been satisfied, like suppose you are fully satiated after eating a heart meal; this state of satiety, of no longer being in need or want, is itself pleasurable.
Epicurus calls this a 'static' pleasure, and says that these static pleasures are the best pleasures, the highest from of pleasure.
Hence, Epicurus says that there is no intermediate state between pleasure and pain.
When one has unfulfilled desires, this is painful, and when one no longer has unfulfilled desires, this steady state is the most pleasurable of all.
There is no intermediate state between pleasure and pain – either your desires are fulfilled or they are not...!
Epicurus also distinguishes between physical and mental pleasures and pains.
Physical pleasures and pains concern only the present, whereas mental pleasures and pains also encompass the past (fond memories of past pleasure or regret over past pain or mistakes) and the future (confidence or fear about what will occur).
The greatest destroyer of happiness is anxiety about the future, especially the fear of death. If you can banish fear about the future, and face the future with confidence that one's desires will be satisfied, then you can attain a most exalted state of tranquillity.
This we see that the key to happiness is the effective management of your desires – Desire Management.
There is a close connection between pleasure and desire-satisfaction.
If pleasure results from getting what you want (desire-satisfaction) and pain from not getting what you want (desire-frustration), then there are two strategies you can pursue with respect to any given desire: you can either strive to fulfil the desire, or you can try to eliminate the desire.
Epicurus advocates the second strategy of scaling down your desires to the basic minimum which can easily be satisfied.
Epicurus distinguishes between three types of desires:
1. natural and necessary desires,
2. natural but non-necessary desires,
3. "vain and empty" or unnatural and unnecessary desires.
How we tackle each of these three types of desires determines our tendency to happiness [or unhappiness].
Examples of natural and necessary desires include the desires for food, shelter,health, sense of security and basic physical needs, cravings which will necessarily lead to greater pain if they are not fulfilled.
These basic desires are easy to satisfy yet difficult to eliminate since they are 'hard-wired' into human beings naturally and bring great pleasure when satisfied ( "Happiness begins at the stomach" )
Furthermore, they are necessary for life, and they are naturally limited: that is, if one is hungry, it only takes a limited amount of food to fill the stomach, after which the desire is satisfied.
Epicurus says that you should try to fulfil natural and necessary desires.
Vain, unnatural and unnecessary desires include desires for excessive power, wealth, fame, and other egoistic ambitions which have all the trappings of status and prestige.
Vain desires are difficult to satisfy, in part because they have no natural limit.
If one desires wealth or power, no matter how much one gets, it is always possible to get more, and the more one gets, the more one wants. These desires are not natural to human beings, but inculcated by society and by false beliefs about what we need, for example, believing that being very powerful or wealthy or famous will guarantee us happiness. In actual fact, Opulence may attract thieves and other dangers, and Power and Fame may attract sycophants.
Epicurus says that such vain and empty desires should be eliminated.
An example of a natural but non-necessary desire is the desire for luxury food. Although food is needed for survival, one does not need rich expensive gourmet food to survive. Thus, despite his hedonism, Epicurus advocates a surprisingly ascetic way of life. Although you shouldn't spurn extravagant foods if they happen to be available, becoming dependent on such luxury food (and other luxuries) ultimately leads to unhappiness.
These natural but non-necessary desires are those cravings that do not necessarily lead to greater pain if they are not fulfilled. These desires are typically recreational in nature: Sexual gratification, aesthetic desires, entertainment, pleasant conversation, the arts, sports, travel etc
In the case of natural but non-necessary desires you must approach life like a banquet. Think of your life as if it were a banquet where you would behave graciously, when dishes are passed to you, extend your hand and help yourself to a moderate portion. If a dish should pass you by, enjoy what is already on your plate. And if a dish hasn't being passed to you yet, patiently wait for your turn.
To paraphrase Epicurus, "If you wish to make a man truly wealthy (happy), don't give him more money; rather, just try to reduce his desires".
By eliminating the pain caused by unfulfilled desires, and the anxiety that occurs because of the fear that one's desires will not be fulfilled in the future, the wise Epicurean attains tranquillity, and thus enjoys happiness.
Copyright © Vikram Karve 2010
Vikram Karve has asserted his right under the Copyright, Designs and Patents Act 1988 to be identified as the author of this work.